The making of a 1936 Knucklehead springer front end

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • fillibuster
    replied
    Originally posted by Kozy View Post
    Jerry, Thanks for the reply and photos. I didn't realize there were differences in the shape of the main brace. You have a great eye for detail.
    Full disclosure: 1. I'm crippled and bored, so have degraded to trolling on Harley threads. 2. I'm uh Indian guy so I can speak with authority on Luland's post #77 in which he denigrates HD and it's employees ----- he is 100% spot on! Dam harley junk, anyway!! ........ that's sincerely meant to be "sporting" only..

    and now honestly: Jerry, you're a man of my heart, I love your work, and the rest of you your attention to all the fine little details in what once must have been a very interestingly documented history. I also envy the technological experiences many of you have that weren't available in average farm and ranch country South Dakota, but in heavy industrialized places like Milwaukee or Springfield Mass, one could more likely have witnessed earlier steel manufacturing. So, cool stuff!

    I've had this little idea (theory, or hallucination), that casting molds were expanded (chisel'd out, shall we say) over time to produce reinforcements. In the example of the spring perch, the earlier mold was merely "relieved" at the outside zero bosses, and at the spring bases, to allow more material into the mold for that reinforcement. Observing Indian castings from earlier transmissions and connecting rods and cylinders, and their progressively heavier more reinforced weak points (not to mention additionally finning) would also prove the theory. What I don't know is, how long (in years) would a mold last, or, how many sand molds were used to produce the thousands (millions?) of cylinders, or rods, or cases, etc.??

    btw, great thread, ... and I do love knuckles, but don't tell

    Leave a comment:


  • Kozy
    replied
    Jerry, Thanks for the reply and photos. I didn't realize there were differences in the shape of the main brace. You have a great eye for detail.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jerry Wieland
    replied
    I personally believe that this is a inline springer with a tweeked stem and other work done.

    This first picture is from the eBay add and shows the bottom of the main brace. The second picture shows a 1948 offset springer that I have and needs help but for reference purposes look at the profile of the leading edge of each and compare.





    This picture is also from the auction and clearly shows a front perch that has been brazed on and that typically is earlier than 1944.



    This last picture shows that brake anchor of the springer in question. Usually where one is brazed so is the other so I therefore believe this springer is not what it is advertised as.



    Jerry

    Leave a comment:


  • Kozy
    replied
    Brazed Offset?

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/141255447562...84.m1423.l2648

    Here's an ebay listing of an offset fork with the rigid leg spring perch brazed and having the inside bosses for grease zerks. Is it possible this is an OEM offset fork or is it an inline with a tweeked stem?

    Leave a comment:


  • Jerry Wieland
    replied
    Finally getting around to posting some more pictures. After doing a bit of research I discovered that Matt was right about the hole placement. An early springer brake anchor hole is almost exactly .100" closer to the leg than the later ones. I do not know if you can see it in this picture or not. 1937 springer on the left (black paint).



    So what I am going to do is weld the hole shut using a wire feed welder. I am using the copper as a heat sink and also the wire will weld up to the copper but will not adhere. It is a good way to fill in holes.





    Then I carefully grind down the weld and if any porosity I weld it up again until I am satisfied. One of the downsides of wire welding (MIG) is that the welds cool fast and as a result it can be very hard to drill so I usually end up annealing it by getting it low red hot and then holding the temperature there for a minute or so and then letting it cool slow.



    Will continue later. Jerry

    Leave a comment:


  • DANPATCH
    replied
    Thanks Jerry the picture of the spring perch

    Leave a comment:


  • painterdale
    replied
    This is cool stuff, Jerry! Very educational thread! Thanks. Dale

    Leave a comment:


  • Jerry Wieland
    replied
    Originally posted by DANPATCH View Post
    You stated the first reinforcing of the spring perch occurred for sure by 1943. So it probably started life as a 1941 or early 1942 piece.What is the difference in the reinforcing spring perch. Thanks
    Dan In post 87 compare my 3rd photo where it is circled to the 2nd photo. It is very obvious. When I get a chance I could also take some side views and post them too.

    Jerry

    Leave a comment:


  • DANPATCH
    replied
    You stated the first reinforcing of the spring perch occurred for sure by 1943. So it probably started life as a 1941 or early 1942 piece.What is the difference in the reinforcing spring perch. Thanks

    Leave a comment:


  • Jerry Wieland
    replied
    Originally posted by Matt McManus View Post
    Jerry,

    this is not the best picture but you can see what I am talking about.
    Matt I have a number of early springers and will be able to get a measurement off of one of them.

    Thanks Jerry

    Leave a comment:


  • Matt McManus
    replied
    Jerry,

    this is not the best picture but you can see what I am talking about.

    Leave a comment:


  • knuckcrazy
    replied
    Originally posted by BigLakeBob View Post
    Bob L, Do you really think they were sand cast? The rear leg is hollow correct? With the shape of the leg how was the form removed from the inside of the leg after casting? Swedged not cast IMHO. I could also see a form die being used, but not cast, when a casting is not solid you need someway to remove the inside core. Bob#6738
    Now a days i think they call it lost core casting, sand is glued in a form then inserted in place for casting. After metal is solid part is vibrated and glued sand is reduced again to sand. Heads on automobile are done this way now, intake and exhaust ports and runners look like a spider when inserted in machine. I agree Swedged.
    And yes some of us are Polish......
    Last edited by knuckcrazy; 01-04-2014, 11:35 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jerry Wieland
    replied
    Originally posted by DANPATCH View Post
    How do you tell the difference in the the first reinforcing of the spring perch that occurred for sure by 1943. Thanks for your time
    Dan There are at least 5 different upper spring perches used on the 1936 and up springer.

    Here is the first version used from 1936 until sometime in 1938.



    Then this second version went from later 1938 until sometime in the early 1940's. I really feel bad about this because I had it all sorted out at one time by getting JWL to look at his original paint bikes but I apparently did not write it down. For sure it is in use until probably early 1942. Grease zerk bosses have been moved to the outside.



    Dan, this is the third version of springer perch that was in use by 1943. I hi-lighted the area of the reinforcement.



    Now when they went to this next one, the fourth version, I do not know but I suspect some time around 1945/46. If anybody can help me out on this one I would appreciate it. The area behind the rod guide hole is now reinforced plus the lip around the hole is beefier but the inside zerk bosses still exist.



    This fifth version I believe came out on the very last of the in-line springers in 1946. All offset springers that I have ever seen have this one. Notice that no evidence of the inside zerk bosses exists anymore.



    Jerry
    Last edited by Jerry Wieland; 01-04-2014, 08:10 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jerry Wieland
    replied
    Originally posted by Matt McManus View Post
    Jerry,

    I know you ground the weld down to make the brake anchor look like it was brazed on but you will also have to modify the length of the lug with the hole in it. The early ones do not stick out as far from the rear leg as the later ones do. This was changed when the locking tab was introduced and the early cotter pin style brake shackle stud was done away with.
    Matt Thanks for the heads up. I thought I checked it out real good but I will double check and see. Jerry

    Leave a comment:


  • Matt McManus
    replied
    Originally posted by Jerry Wieland View Post
    The brake anchor needs to have the weld disappear and be brazed. I have not had much luck trying to braze with a torch what HD brazed with a furnace. It is hard to get enough heat into the fork to get the braze to fuse without getting too much heat. So what I do is dress the weld until it no longer looks like a weld. I have had a fair amount of practice doing this because over the years I have fixed quite a few Indian frames that had 'slipped joints'. The late Indian frames were very poorly brazed and it is not uncommon to have a joint pull apart. I would remove the tube and then because I no luck with brazing the big bulky Indian castings, I would weld them and then have to dress them back to appear not welded.

    Before



    After


    Jerry,

    I know you ground the weld down to make the brake anchor look like it was brazed on but you will also have to modify the length of the lug with the hole in it. The early ones do not stick out as far from the rear leg as the later ones do. This was changed when the locking tab was introduced and the early cotter pin style brake shackle stud was done away with.

    Leave a comment:

Working...