The making of a 1936 Knucklehead springer front end
Collapse
X
-
How do you tell the difference in the the first reinforcing of the spring perch that occurred for sure by 1943. Thanks for your time
-
I recall reading an article about the reintroduction of the springer back in the 90s. The article said H-D brought in an old employee who had swaged springer tubing for many years. Apparently, there was a great deal of technique involved in getting them right and that aspects of the process could not be plainly documented. That is not very hard to imagine considering you don't make a leg with one simple blow of a forging die.
Leave a comment:
-
Robert L., Sorry but you are talking out of the wrong orfice. The tubes are swaged. Harley explains the manufacturing process on page 12 of the "Lets Visit the Harley Davidson Factory". Maybe someone could scan it and post it. The short story is that they begin as 1 1/2" plain straight tubes. They speak of the swaging machine steps and dies.
Leave a comment:
-
Bob, you beat me to my post. Chris, you are most likely right about the swaging thing. I have a bad habit of looking at everything in today’s labor market and saying to myself, why would anyone in their right mind go through all that labor to make a radius rod but the reality is labor at the time was dirt cheap. I’m sticking to my theory on the dent thou. It makes too much sense. Bob L
Leave a comment:
-
Bob L, Do you really think they were sand cast? The rear leg is hollow correct? With the shape of the leg how was the form removed from the inside of the leg after casting? Swedged not cast IMHO. I could also see a form die being used, but not cast, when a casting is not solid you need someway to remove the inside core. Bob#6738
Leave a comment:
-
The '36 E shift lever was swaged tube. I see no reason why the legs weren't swaged. A cast part would have a texture on it and be brittle. Sadly AMF tossed all the documents telling how to make parts.
Leave a comment:
-
I’ve held off giving my view on this subject till now. Let’s get real here. The motor company was in the business of making motorcycles. Not some exotic bullshit. These drunken Pollacks probably had to put together four of these and hour are they were unemployed. The lower legs and top legs were both casted. Did you think for one minute that Harley had some magical wan that made tubes reduce size laterally. You can cast chrome molly just the same way you can cast 1018 carbon steel. The finish is dependent upon what type of sand you’re using and how tight it’s packed. The design was great, top tube fit into the bottom tube in the braces. Insert reinforcement sleeve and you’re done. Now let’s talk about jigs. They didn’t have pneumatic or electrical servo motors. What they did have were simple screw vices that locked all this crap together prior to putting it in the furnace. How much you want to bet that one of the vices lost its holding pad and the screw was allowed to in dent the side of the fork tube until one of these brain surgeons caught it. Harley was cheap. Dent or not that fork want on the shelf. Do you think for one minute that the consumer ever gave a damm. Extrusion process is for aluminum. Bob L
Leave a comment:
-
OK guys, I dug out the last early springer leg that I think I have. It is a little rusty but actually a pretty nice front end except some Bozo back in the past did a poor job of straightening the lower legs. This is the 5th one I have looked at and not one of the first 4 had the little dent but guess what.

At first glance this one does not look like it has a dent either but I could fell something ever so slightly with my fingers. Then when you shut off the flash and get the natural light just right - presto. This is the left leg.

Right leg.

So both legs on this springer show at least some distortion. The pictures are a bit fuzzy because it took my camera about 10 seconds to intake enough light to get a decent picture - I guess I am shakier than I thought.
OK after further analysis these dents are less severe than what I was anticipating. 2 of the other 4 early legs that I looked were once chromed and it is quite possible that dents could have been polished out during the chroming but that still leaves 2 painted early springers with absolutely no dents.
We have a sonar device at work for measuring wall thickness on pipes that we use 2 twice a year to measure inside erosion on critical cooling pipes. I think it just found another job - measuring wall thickness on those 2 chromed springer legs. I'll report back when I have any results.
JerryLast edited by Jerry Wieland; 01-01-2014, 03:45 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
Definitely a dimple on my 36' springer rear legs ( both sides ). JL
No real history to pass on. Bought 'em offn Ebay yearz an yearz ago. JL
Leave a comment:
-
The original sales booklet that I have for 1937 has a picture of the springer with wording that says "Chrome moli tube front forks for extra strength"
I am at my beach house, so I can't scan and share at the moment.
Chris, have you heard of this phenomena prior to this thread?
They still make springer front forks. It would be great to know how they form the legs.
I think the rear legs are the most interesting/complicated part that HD made.
Leave a comment:



Leave a comment: