Indian motorcycle name change

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • ryan
    replied
    Speaking of Indians, a collector up the street just got in some board track racers and a couple of hill climbers. I think he is building one of the nicest and largest collections I have ever seen. Oh, he also just got in a Thor with a sidecar. All the bikes are for sale if anyone is looking for anything.

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by ryan View Post
    You and I need to have a chat on the phone and not on this site. Lol
    Agreed. Back to motorcycles.

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Aho, kemenwipematethi? No, no, no, I was not going into that at all, I know people were not treated well, but that is recorded as so. I was talking about the cancelling of history and only history. You cannot punish people from the past, nor change their point of view by erasing what people thought or did or punish the people of today for what the people of yesterday did.
    I was not even thinking of blacks doing this, but the marxist groups, but since you brought them up. I go to a black owned bodyshop daily, in the "hood", and hear the N word more in one day than I ever have in my life prior to doing so. Go spend some time in these communities as I do, listen to what the people have to say, put air in their kids bikes, tighten their chains and what not, get the minibikes running, buy their candybars. They will tell you who tries to keep them down and you may be amazed by the answers. I would much rather be black with two legs than be who I am with one leg.
    My dad is a Sauk America Indian, but I am not a member of the tribe, he did not register my brother, sister or myself because he wanted us to make that dicision. We are only Indian if we are registered with a tribe and have a blood quantum card. Only three things in America are registered with blood, horses, dogs and Indians.
    A Spanish person, Spain is part of Europe mind you that did more killing and enslaving people than any English or Americans, gets minority benefits no questions asked, but an American Indian without a quantum card cannot. Ask my dad how his parents kept their farms when fdr's Indian renewal act, that was suppose to help Indians on the reservations, but on the other hand, was trying to put Indians back on the reservations and stealing their farms.
    No matter what happened in our history, we have grown, with growing pains, I might add. Today, the only person being held back is by ones self. You and I need to have a chat on the phone and not on this site. Lol

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by ryan View Post
    I will not apologize to any of the cancel culturelist, you cannot change history because it makes you feel good,
    Sometime in the early 1960s I saw the 1943 movie 'Corregidor' on TV and vividly remember one character in the movie saying to another that she could do something because she was "free, white, and twenty-one." It struck such a cord that I immediately asked my mother what it meant (I watched that movie again in more recent time and that scene is missing). Until 1949 the AMA rulebook explicitly banned "negroes" from competition, and in the early 1960s it was common to hear the n-word used in everyday conversation.

    Those are part of "history," and I certainly wouldn't want anyone to forget they actually are part of history, but it's not "cancel-culture" to object to those terms being used today. Not wanting those terms used isn't to make someone feel good, it's to not to treat others as less than equal. I would hope that if Sucher were writing his book today that he would be aware enough of positive changes in the world around him over the past 43 years that he would use a different title.

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by T. Cotten View Post
    No need to apologize to me, Ryan!

    I understand.

    Apologize to those who now are re-writing our History, over and over; As if it would do any good.

    ....Cotten
    I will not apologize to any of the cancel culturelist, you cannot change history because it makes you feel good, yesterday is gone! On with the future!

    Indian is a great name and would represent any people well!
    Last edited by ryan; 07-22-2020, 07:47 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • tfburke3
    replied
    When I was kid my dad called everyone chief if he didnt know their name.
    Times do change,especially what causes some be appalled.
    This thread lead me to some internet info about the use of native american indian imagery in advertising.Interesting stuff.
    Tom

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    In the 1950s Floyd Clymer published a series of seven volumes of a "Motor Scrapbook," consisting of reprints of early clippings from newspapers and magazines. In an undated piece printed after Hendee's death (which was in 1943) a photo shows him on a 1901 Indian and says about him "Known as the 'Big Chief' of the Indian wigwam, Hendee was in active control for many years."

    I'll go out on a limb and speculate that if today the president of a, say, car company was described in a newspaper as the 'Big Chief' of the Ford wigwam, most readers would be appalled. Times change. It's hardly rewriting history to point out that some things that might have been acceptable 70 years ago aren't acceptable today.

    Leave a comment:


  • KNUCK
    replied
    Bottom line is that the name of Indian motorcycle was not meant to be derogatory and nor was the name Iron redskin book. It is all in a persons negative twisted mind, and many people are infected with this new type of yet unnamed virus. I have heard that this new virus did not originate in China but in our own schools of higher education.

    Leave a comment:


  • RichO
    replied
    Indian

    I'm surprised no one mentioned the elephant in the room. Most early Indians pre-Dupont were red in color. Just sayin'.

    Leave a comment:


  • T. Cotten
    replied
    Originally posted by ryan View Post
    Yes, you are correct, Cotten, I stand corrected, darn pain or medication and the heat is just brutal here in Ohio. I couldn't even think of The Little Big Horn when I wrote that. That is pretty bad when when an engineer messes that simple math up. Lol. Oh well, it sure sounded good to me at the time when I wrote it.
    No need to apologize to me, Ryan!

    I understand.

    Apologize to those who now are re-writing our History, over and over; As if it would do any good.

    ....Cotten
    Last edited by T. Cotten; 07-22-2020, 04:43 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by T. Cotten View Post
    I think the 50th anniversary of Custer's demise would have been 1926, Ryan!

    Which would be a generation too late to influence Hendee.

    Whatever the reason Folks,.. We can be sure its 'wrong' now.

    ....Cotten
    Yes, you are correct, Cotten, I stand corrected, darn pain or medication and the heat is just brutal here in Ohio. I couldn't even think of The Little Big Horn when I wrote that and had 1926 on my mind instead of 1923. Oh well, it sure sounded good when I wrote it.

    A generation to late? I thought the name was changed to Indian in 1923?
    Last edited by ryan; 07-22-2020, 04:37 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • T. Cotten
    replied
    Originally posted by ryan View Post
    Look what is going on right now with the attacks on our history and the efforts made to do cancel it. I'm sure it happened back then as well.
    It was the 50th anniversary of the battle of the greasy grass when LTC Custard lost his life in 1924, maybe this had an impact on them naming the bike Indian. Talks of the Plain's Indians would have definitely been going on that year
    I think the 50th anniversary of Custer's demise would have been 1926, Ryan!

    Which would be a generation too late to influence Hendee.

    Whatever the reason Folks,.. We can be sure its 'wrong' now.

    ....Cotten

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by exeric View Post
    A lot of people make stuff up to suit their own concept of history, so it's important to find the most accurate material you can.
    Look what is going on right now with the attacks on our history and the efforts made to do cancel it. I'm sure it happened back then as well.
    It was the 50th anniversary of the battle of the greasy grass when LTC Custard lost his life in 1924, maybe this had an impact on them naming the bike Indian. Talks of the Plain's Indians would have definitely been going on that year

    Leave a comment:


  • exeric
    replied
    C2K, I can't stress enough how informative Don Emde's book is, and how enjoyable it is to read. As for domestic competition in 1901, there was Orient, and DeDion based cycles used most exclusively for bicycle pacing, so there really wasn't any competition for motorized cycles that could be ridden on the street. Other books that are factual, and well researched are: 'At The Creation' by Herbert Wagner, and books by Stephen Wright, and Jerry Hatfield. These authors are historians who have done the tireless pursuit of research. A lot of people make stuff up to suit their own concept of history, so it's important to find the most accurate material you can.

    Leave a comment:


  • T. Cotten
    replied
    Originally posted by ChiefTwoKicks View Post
    I'm wondering if the Hendee Mfg. Co. really cared much about the political impact of calling their new invention "Indian", or was it more of an advertising gimmick to market their product against the competition of all the other fledging motorcycle builders ? ......
    The History I was taught, C2K,...

    Was that the fashion fad of the turn of the 20th Century was to glorify the "primitive".
    (Like Stravinsky's 'Rite of Spring',.. etc.)

    You never miss something 'til its gone.

    Especially History.

    ....Cotten
    Last edited by T. Cotten; 07-22-2020, 11:59 AM.

    Leave a comment:

Working...