Indian motorcycle name change

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • ChiefTwoKicks
    replied
    I'm wondering if the Hendee Mfg. Co. really cared much about the political impact of calling their new invention "Indian", or was it more of an advertising gimmick to market their product against the competition of all the other fledging motorcycle builders ? The "machine shop on every corner" concept had to be worrisome for Hendee&Hedstrom, after a hefty investment, albeit with much fanfare and engineering prowess acknowledged universally at expositions in big cities like NY and Chicago, etc. How would the partners raise money enough to began producing significant numbers of machines to be profitable ?

    The word "indian" was getting alot of attention in the papers... I assume anyone who saw an "indian", whether an actual tribal member or a motorcycle, would cause a stir. Without a doubt. The conversation would quickly become one of description and identity, these "indians" were new to everyone, and seeing one (either one)was a novel experience for most.

    I remember in the early 50's, my great grandma (she lived to be 100yrs), told me the story of when she saw her first airplane, landing in a field in western Illinois. She fainted !! Imagine a similar reaction when someone first saw a motorcycle, any motorcycle, especially one with the word INDIAN painted on the tank, back around 1901. I can see it now... "I just saw an Indian", WOW ! Wouldn't that cause quite a stir? I suspect Hendee & Hedstrom (especially, the later) were trying to raise money for their fledgling new contraption. Bicycles weren't making the news much anymore, and the new "motorcycle" was beginning to get all the attention. Oscar Hedstrom was known as the "pitchman", and I speculate the partners put the name "INDIAN" on the machine to attract more attention, thus increasing their market share. It seemed to work out well. Indian sales went off the chart for close to 20 years, compared to the competition. The remaining MC builders played catch up, or closed up shop.

    Its all conjecture now, history is often quite vague. WE only really "know" what we see. Even then, we can be fooled by illusions and the slight of hand. Time passes, and leaves us with an obscure tale, sometimes documented (oftentimes, embellished) for us to capture and wonder what it once was, back in the day. We, in our passionate pursuit of motorcycles suck this stuff up like a sponge. I proud of what I've learned about old bikes. Now, I get to tell the stories (I'm still just a pup, at 71). I do get a bit dismayed when someone asks me "How many 'Indians' did Harley make ? at least I can set them straight.

    C2K

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by exeric View Post
    Please keep us up to date, and I'll mention that as a Christmas gift idea to my wife
    Will do. But, to add some Indian content to this, we will have some seldom-seen Indians in the exhibition, including the last streamliner Burt Munro rode at Bonneville, and the beautiful pre-1910 special made for the female stunt rider C'Dora who rode it for a decade in the Globe of Death.

    Leave a comment:


  • exeric
    replied
    Please keep us up to date, and I'll mention that as a Christmas gift idea to my wife

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by exeric View Post
    I gather your book 'The Motorcycle: Design, Art, Desire' will be available in December of this year. It's the readers that really benefit from a book, so It will be a privilege, and a pleasure to get a copy.
    Thanks very much for that. We've been going through the proofs with a fine-tooth comb this week because on Friday it will go to the typesetter. The lead time is such, especially with the disruptions to the supply chain caused by covid, that it has to be to the printer early in August to be delivered to Brisbane in time for the opening on November 28. I'm not sure if the December date given on Amazon is when it will be released in general, or was just an early estimate the publisher gave Amazon for its general availability. In any case, it will be on Amazon and in bookstores in time to have one under your Christmas tree.

    Leave a comment:


  • cscott
    replied
    thanks for that info

    Leave a comment:


  • exeric
    replied
    I gather your book 'The Motorcycle: Design, Art, Desire' will be available in December of this year. It's the readers that really benefit from a book, so It will be a privilege, and a pleasure to get a copy.

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by BoschZEV View Post
    Sorry. Sometimes I do try to be fairly complete in my responses, but sometimes I take the less time-consuming approach and just want to point out an error so someone else won't think what they just read is correct. Since this is a motorcycle forum, getting into how Columbus referred to the peoples he met is getting pretty far off topic. Besides, anything I wrote would be on the internet, and hence not to be trusted without independently checking it.
    Yes, i agree, I have also read that on several tribal websites, not meaning they are right either. Reading my quote, did not look to good as well and I didn't mean for it to look snotty for say as I did not mean for it to come across that way. But if one may think it is a controversial term, we may as know where the term originated in the first place and we can probably agree that Indios means Indian in either Spanish or Latin that translates to Indian in the English language.
    Back to the subject, we know when the Hendee Manufacturing named it Indian, but it was simply named Indian because of the pioneering tradition?
    Last edited by ryan; 07-21-2020, 11:51 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by ryan View Post
    Just tell me how and why without spouting out incomplete information leaving out the how and why.
    Sorry. Sometimes I do try to be fairly complete in my responses, but sometimes I take the less time-consuming approach and just want to point out an error so someone else won't think what they just read is correct. Since this is a motorcycle forum, getting into how Columbus referred to the peoples he met is getting pretty far off topic. Besides, anything I wrote would be on the internet, and hence not to be trusted without independently checking it.

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by BoschZEV View Post
    That's simply wrong, and illustrates the problem of using the internet as a source of information.

    As for "The Iron Redskin," I agree it's an excellent book. It's just too bad he chose that title when he wrote it over 40 years ago. There are a number of terms for various ethnic and religious groups that were common, widely used across society, and seemingly acceptable years ago that are now recognized as racist and offensive today. At least, recognized by most people. However, if someone doesn't accept this, nothing I write is likely to change their mind so I'll step away from this discussion.
    I may agree that it may have been a bad translation on some one's part many centuries ago, I learned that well before the internet, in college in fact. It came from a letter written to the queen and king of Spain from Columbus. From what I remember, his Spanish Captain logged referred to the natives as Indios, but not the children of God, but this is referenced in several translations of Christopher Columbus's voyages. Now India was called several things throughout the centuries with most names referencing the Indus river I think it is called as well as Hindus, I believe.
    I do not reference anything from the internet nor do internet research, one thing 7 years of college taught me is how to do research and never trust the internet. I can only be as right as what is published after checking multiple references. If I am proved wrong, that's ok, I will retract and learn from my mistake. Just tell me how and why without spouting out incomplete information leaving out the how and why.

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by exeric View Post
    Anything written by Harry Sucher must be subject to peer review;
    Don Emde's fantastic (and currently available) book "The Speed Kings" as advertised in our club magazine,
    Members need to support historians, researchers, and authors who often do this at a financial, and personal time loss because they love this stuff as much as we do.
    A lot of valuable information has come to light since Harry wrote his Indian, and H-D books.
    +1 I completely agree with everything you wrote.

    On the subject of books, I recently completed a "Selected Bibliography" for a motorcycle book https://www.amazon.com/Motorcycle-De...5374921&sr=8-1 I'm co-authoring in conjunction with 'The Motorcycle: Design, Art, Desire' exhibition https://blog.qagoma.qld.gov.au/the-m...ect-of-desire/ that will open at QAGOMA in Brisbane, Australia on November 28.

    In selecting books to represent individual brands, sometimes it was difficult because, although there might have been only three or four books for a given lesser marque, all of them are comprehensive, well-written, well-researched, well-documented histories. However, in the case of Indian and Harley-Davidson, although there are literally hundreds of books, it was difficult because very few are anything more than seemingly-random collections of photographs tied together with words that often are pulled out of the air rather than based on any sort of research or documentation.

    Leave a comment:


  • exeric
    replied
    Anything written by Harry Sucher must be subject to peer review; which he didn't always seek. George Hendee made the Indian bicycle before he and Oscar Hedstrom developed their motorcycle. All of this is very well documented in Don Emde's fantastic (and currently available) book "The Speed Kings" as advertised in our club magazine, with a discount for AMCA members. Members need to support historians, researchers, and authors who often do this at a financial, and personal time loss because they love this stuff as much as we do. A lot of valuable information has come to light since Harry wrote his Indian, and H-D books.
    Last edited by exeric; 07-21-2020, 06:29 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • BoschZEV
    replied
    Originally posted by ryan View Post
    Columbus called the peoples of first contact, the Indio people, meaning children of God.
    That's simply wrong, and illustrates the problem of using the internet as a source of information.

    As for "The Iron Redskin," I agree it's an excellent book. It's just too bad he chose that title when he wrote it over 40 years ago. There are a number of terms for various ethnic and religious groups that were common, widely used across society, and seemingly acceptable years ago that are now recognized as racist and offensive today. At least, recognized by most people. However, if someone doesn't accept this, nothing I write is likely to change their mind so I'll step away from this discussion.

    Leave a comment:


  • ChiefTwoKicks
    replied
    After reading the post from cscott wondering how the name INDIAN came about I looked in my copy of The Iron Redskin, by Harry Sucher. Sucher is regarded as the premier authority on the history of the iconic marquee. His research is legendary, and if anyone would know, it would be Harry. Here's what I found...

    On page 25, near the top of the page it states, "The trade name of INDIAN was selected by the founders as that best typifying a wholly American product in the pioneer tradition." The actual name of the founding company was "The Hendee Manufacturing Company". Later, with the reorganization of the company in 1923, after many years of declining sales and loss of revenue, the Board of Directors met in November of 1923 and formally renamed the company "INDIAN MOTOCYCLE COMPANY", replacing the name Hendee Manufacturing Company, which had operated since 1901, when first organized by Hendee and Hedstrom. (pg. 143). Further noting, the continuing speculation throughout the years the reason for dropping the "r" from the word motorcycle in the company name. According to company records of the Board's action, this was done to avoid any possible legal action arising from any patent infringments, which in the early days of auto and motoccycle manufactures. INDIAN became a publicly offered stock, ipo @ $25/share. It was rumored (but never validated) that Pierre S. duPont had underwritten the initial public offering. (pg. 143et,al.) According to Sucher, there was a serious battle for financial control of many of the fledgling automobile and motorcycle manufactures throughout the troubling times of the early twenties.

    There's a whole lot more in this wonderful book. Considered the bible of the famous brand, this book is filled with legendary hero's exploits and accurate data of historical records. There is even a picture of the LosAngeles 45 Motorcycle Club on a "Steak Run" to Camp Comfort in Ojai, Ca. in Aug, 1932. (pg.232) That park is in my immediate neighborhood, about 4 miles from where I live. A very beautiful county park, with lots of shady oak trees. I can certainly imagine why the guys would ride up to Ojai from L.A. to enjoy a beautiful day of riding, and a big steak dinner !! I ride by that park 2-3 times a week just to decompress from the hustle and bustle of daily life. Such a blessing where I live. Ojai is a native Indian word for "Shangrla", and this place is very much a paradise around here. (even though its here in California, I'm not leaving anytime soon. Can't get any closer to heaven than this. I digress...

    Hope this answers cscott's inquiry. There's magic in the name "Indian" C2K

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by cscott View Post
    wonder how they came up with the name indian in the first place?
    Do not read the website Quora, he has things all wrong about American Indians and how they got the name. India got their name India centuries after Columbus called the peoples of first contact, the Indio people, meaning children of God. Just wanted to get that part straightened up and the American Indian prefers to be called just that bc everyone born in the western hemisphere is a native American. Next time someone says, we are all immigrants, ask them what country they were born in.
    A little oft track, but I thought it needed to be said.
    I am not sure why Hendee named his bicycle or his "Motocycle" Indian.

    Leave a comment:


  • ryan
    replied
    Originally posted by jcrawford View Post
    I say the more appropriate name for the current models produced is POLARIAN, (which is not to offend anyone of Polish heritage!)
    As for the genuine, real and historic Springfield models, leave it alone and let it be! There was nothing at all offensive then or now.
    Same for Chicago hockey and Cleveland and Atlanta baseball teams. (Just my 2 bits)
    John
    I agree, the name paid great homage to the American Indian people.

    Leave a comment:

Working...