How Many Knuckleheads still kicking

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kozy
    replied
    Originally posted by fxcw64 View Post
    I can see now how wrong my original assumption was with the UL and EL hybrid --So for someone like me that sounds like alot of machine work putting heads on a bottom end that uses 4 cams instead of the single cam set up it came with!!!
    I really can't wrap my head around that .....The angles seem all wrong WOW
    Unless you just machine the covers to go over the ..........nope thats not it ------so do you just machine the UL heads to accept Knucklehead covers ???

    Rubberband brain stretched to limits LOL -thats a headscratcher you got there 1950Panhead
    Look here for some insight.t http://victorylibrary.com/45MAG.htm

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    I can see now how wrong my original assumption was with the UL and EL hybrid --So for someone like me that sounds like alot of machine work putting heads on a bottom end that uses 4 cams instead of the single cam set up it came with!!!
    I really can't wrap my head around that .....The angles seem all wrong WOW
    Unless you just machine the covers to go over the ..........nope thats not it ------so do you just machine the UL heads to accept Knucklehead covers ???

    Rubberband brain stretched to limits LOL -thats a headscratcher you got there 1950Panhead

    Leave a comment:


  • 1950Panhead
    replied
    Hey guys question
    If a Knucklehead has a UL # then it is a UL bottom(flathead) end with El or FL heads/jugs correct. True Knucks were only EL or FL ?
    As Robbie says, knucklehead and UL and engines are completely different.
    A few four cam knuckles have been built.

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    You guys are awesome !!! Thanks

    Leave a comment:


  • Peter Cooke
    replied
    This might help.

    Leave a comment:


  • Rubone
    replied
    U and UL=74SV UH and ULH=80SV. W, WL, WLA, WLC, WLJ, WLH, G = 45. E, EL =61 OHV, and F,FL, FLH, FLE = 74OHV

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    Wow Thanks Rubone you saved me from looking like a fool !! And you are correct I was mislead and that is straightened out with your help- the guy thought because the years were the same he had a knucklehead and gave me that # and I was confused since I had never known of a UL Knuck but figured it was the equivalent of people doing a Pan head/Shoval bottom.
    I guess I should have been able to figure this out since UL and WL are all either 74'' or 80'' correct ? and the early Knucks were 61'' cubic inches !!

    Plus I never saw the heads on said bike it was just a pic !!

    Leave a comment:


  • Rubone
    replied
    Originally posted by fxcw64 View Post
    Hey guys question
    If a Knucklehead has a UL # then it is a UL bottom(flathead) end with El or FL heads/jugs correct. True Knucks were only EL or FL ?

    Chris H- I have looked at your site and will continue Thanks
    No, not anywhere near correct. If it has a UL number it is almost 100% a restamp. The bottom ends are totally different and although it is possible to build such a hybrid, it is outside the ability of most and is not at all a common engine. The total existence could be counted on one hand.

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    Hey guys question
    If a Knucklehead has a UL # then it is a UL bottom(flathead) end with El or FL heads/jugs correct. True Knucks were only EL or FL ?

    Chris H- I have looked at your site and will continue Thanks

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    MMatt
    Speaking of books I picked up Harley Davidson Knuckleheads by Field and am currently enjoying it !

    Leave a comment:


  • montuckymatt
    replied
    Originally posted by exeric View Post
    I based my reply on Excelsior, and Henderson production data that is still sketchy; despite the profound efforts of Bund/Turek. It seems that history only remembers the things that get into print, regardless of accuracy. For many years, and perhaps still, many people think H-D started in 1903. Herbert Wagner did exhaustive research to present better data that puts that date at (circa) 1905, but H-D has perpetuated the story of 1903 to the point that no one questions them. The bulk of knuckleheads were built in the '30s and I would bet that the real production numbers are only known by studying the complexities of engine, and line bore numbers. The true history of knuckleheads (and perhaps all H-Ds) was lost when AMF (and fate) chose to destroy the mountains of priceless documented factory production data. Again, Herbert Wagner wrote an incredible article about the Lang connection in our magazine a few years ago. He also wrote one of my favorite motorcycle books 'Harley-Davidson 1930-1941'. If you love Harleys, you need to have that book in your collection.
    I added this book to my collection after reading your post. I found a copy on amazon for under 5 bucks. I started it last night and couldn't put it down! What a fantastic read! Thanks for the recommendation.

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    [QUOTE=Chris Haynes;183076]
    Originally posted by fxcw64 View Post
    And the point of doing such a tally would be to do it accurately -but if your point is their are people here knowledgeable enough and are not AMCA judges that could do it--I believe you

    Luke

    Spend a little time here and it will help you understand how to spot bad numbers.
    http://vintageamericanmotorcycles.com/v/Numbers/


    Thanks Chris H -I will check out !

    Leave a comment:


  • Chris Haynes
    replied
    [QUOTE=fxcw64;183075]And the point of doing such a tally would be to do it accurately -but if your point is their are people here knowledgeable enough and are not AMCA judges that could do it--I believe you

    Luke

    Spend a little time here and it will help you understand how to spot bad numbers.

    Leave a comment:


  • fxcw64
    replied
    Originally posted by Chris Haynes View Post
    You certainty don't need to be a judge in order to be knowledgeable about numbers.
    Chris
    Well my grandaughter knows her numbers so what parameters would you prefer -someone who has seen counterfit numbers and has been in a role inspecting bikes AND represents the AMCA or some one like me who knows nada about how the 7 or 5 should look stamped on the crankcase of a Knucklehead- I have read on this board people commenting about counterfit stampings.

    And the point of doing such a tally would be to do it accurately -but if your point is their are people here knowledgeable enough and are not AMCA judges that could do it--I believe you

    Luke

    My wife has volunteered to make an excel spreadsheet if needed but still need verification before data is entered.

    I took pics of 4 today at Old Glory HD and have their numbers but may not have all the owners but could find that info out !

    Leave a comment:


  • ammorest
    replied
    Here's a couple more. The gray 1945 and the green 1938 on the cover of Bruce Palmer's books are titled, licensed, and ridden.
    Dave

    Leave a comment:

Working...