Exterior oil Filter

[Will]

I am going to change my oil filter and I would like some advice. I have come up with to part numbers for the canister inside the exterior oil filter. The first one is 63839-53 ( what looks like a modern metal canister with filter inside) and 63840-48a ( what looks like paper or cloth roll).
Questions: Which one is the best for flow, cleaning the oil, and general durability?

My bike is a rider that will never see a judging event, so authenticity is not as important as serviceability.

Thanks for your attention
W

[vph-d]

Since originality isn't a consideration, why not use one of the aftermarket kits that hang a spin-on oil filter next to the oil tank? I've got two of them, and haven't had any problems. I buy the replacement spin on filters at an H-D dealer.
VPH-D

[Will]

Thanks for that tip but the old canister is already installed and I like the way it looks. Just looking for which filter seem better or if there is a difference that I should know about
Thanks again
W

[vph-d]

The -48 number is for the external cannister. The -53 number is for in-tank XLs and FL models.
VPH-D

[Will]

Thanks again that is just the information I was looking for. You guys are great
W

[duffeycycles]

http://www.vtwinmfg.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/VTwinProd1_10101_10102_3312536_-1